In the
movie “Smoke Signals”, the symbol of fire was very important. It is key to understanding this symbol in
order to fully understand the true meaning of the movie. Throughout the movie, fire is seen and
affects all of the characters greatly.
First
of all, the first time we see fire is when Arnold is saving Thomas from his
burning house. His parents die in this
fire, but Thomas is thrown out the window and saved. During this part Thomas is also narrating and
comparing children to flames and ashes.
Thomas states, “You know there are some children who aren't really
children at all, they're just pillars of flame that burn everything they touch.
And there are some children who are just pillars of ash, that fall apart when
you touch them... Victor and me, we were children of flame and ash.” This really gives a key insight into what
flames mean. You can see this
comparison throughout the whole movie with the two boys. Victor always seems to have an anger issue
(mostly because his father left him) and Thomas just has such a sensitive and
caring soul. It seems fitting that
Thomas is the ashes because he was in the fire and lost everything, therefore
he’d be the end result of the fire and its destruction. Victor is still the flame, because he has all
of this anger pent up inside of him. His
fire is still raging on and until he can come to terms with this, he will never
get to ashes.
The
other place that fire is seen is when Suzy Song burns down Arnold’s
trailer. I think that after Thomas’
parents died, Arnold kind of started to become ashes as well. He was just breaking himself down, especially
with his alcoholism, and finally he became ashes himself (being cremated). The burning down of his trailer signifies
this. And, although this may be
stretching it a bit... I feel as the burning of his trailer finally allowed him
to become FLAMES again, after having been ashes for so long. It was his last time at being strong and
almighty flames. It is also significant that Suzy gives the
boys Arnold’s ashes, because this further strengthens the correlation.
I
really like the connection between fire between this movie and the book “The
Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian.”
In that book, the main character also lost a significant family member
due to alcohol and fire. I think, due to
the connection with the alcohol, the fire signifies the lost hope of the Native
Americans and also just their pure anger at how society still is towards them
as a culture and a heritage.
Overall,
I really think that the symbol of the fire, flames and ashes really help to
strengthen the movie and helps us understand the characters and their pain even
more. Underlying messages are usually
always the strongest and have the most impact on us as viewers.
I really liked your analysis of the meaning of fire. I especially found it interesting how you said until Victor can let go of his anger he can't get to the ashes. I never thought of it as something that he was trying to get to, but it makes sense, especially if you think about the comparison made in class about how a Phoenix rises from its ashes. He will never be able to be reborn if he doesn"t get to the ashes in the first place.
ReplyDeleteWhen I thought about fire and its role in Smoke Signals I never really thought of it as having so much meaning to how Victor and Thomas live their lives. Fire has influenced both of their lives in an irreversible way and they have to learn to overcome its effects. I always thought of fire as a sort of rebirth. Victor was able to be reborn through his father's death and after learning about why his father did what he did, Victor is able to move on from the past. I also like how you said Victor was the fire and Thomas was the ashes. Victor has a very fiery temper and can't seem to let go of his rage, while Thomas is now content with his life after the fire. Fire has a whole lot of more meaning than just rebirth and it has a significant role in how Victor's and Thomas's lives play out.
ReplyDeleteAll of the aspects you discussed are very relavent to many Native American films. I especially think the fire was a huge part of the movie. I like how you brought the symbolic meaning of fire and how it symbolizes the rebirth of the characters Victor, Thomas, and Victor's father. Victor gets the chance to live a different life, a life to restart on the reservation. One with hope and a future in sight. Thomas was the only one that survived the fire that killed his parents. Phoenix, the city his father moved to, has significance in the sense that it's a mythical bird reborn from his ashes. You did a great analysis of how fire is the central idea throughout Smoke Signals.
ReplyDelete